Textuality » 3LSCA Interacting

SNardella - exemple of an argumentative text "A word is dead" - 21/11/2019
by SNardella - (2019-11-21)
Up to  3LSCA - Argumentative Text WritingUp to task document list

“A word is dead”

A word is dead

when it is said

some say

 

I  say

It just begins to live

That day

 

TITLE: “A word is dead”

What do expect the poem will be about?

1)      Considering the title I expect the poem may be about the death of comunication.

2)      I think the poem will be about a form of comunication that is no longer true

3)      I expect the poem will be about a word will be never said again.

When you read the title, what thing the reader wants to find out? What curiosity?

The reader is curious to discover / to find out why the word is “dead”

CONSIDERING THE LAY-OUT and TEXT STRUCTURE:

Considering the lay-out the reader realizes/ can see the text is organised into/is arranged into 2 stanzas of 3 lines each.

The poem consists in six lines organized into 2 tercets , thereforhe would like to understand/ find out the reason why the poet/poetes has arranged the message into 2 stanzas and last but not least the function of each stanzas.

DENOTATIVE ANALYSIS:

The poem expresses 2 points of view about the life of a word. Some people think that whenever you say a word it dies, the poetes believes that when someone says a word, it starts to live.

The function of the first stanzas is to report common people’s idea about the life of the word; the function of the second tercets is to report the poetes’ opinion. It follows that/ as a result/ as a consequence the intelligent reader can understand that the lay-out has been concived to present two opposites/ contrasting ideas about the nature of words.

CONNOTATIVE ANALYSIS:

-livello fonologico

The poem has got the following scheme: AABCDB

The first and the second line are run-on-lines. The use of the come at the end of the second line is really important.

The last one tercets is a run-on line too. Sintax is turned up-side down in the second tercets: the first tercets makes use a run-on-line, in the second tercets what take place is exactly the opposite.