Learning Paths » 5A Interacting
EMongera - 5A - Modernism and postmodernism - Class test
by 2011-12-20)
- (
EXPECTED RESULT OF THE CLASS TEST
- The word Post-modernism
well displays the movement cultural features and contradictions: first of
all it implies a relationship with Modernism since at the same time it
comes diachronically after, but also goes beyond some of its tenets. As it
always happens with something new, at the beginning it is considered with
suspect. - Modernism and
Post-modernism while constantly having a mutual silent dialogue are
totally different as far as the way they consider truth, because while
Modernists still believed in the possibility to find a meaning which could
give relevance to their existence and they followed personal quests in
this direction, Postmodernists do not even think to look for truth as a
single unique point of reference because they do not believe there is one. - Inter-textuality is a
cultural and narrative technique which openly displays references to other
texts in different ways ranging from inner influence, structural
frameworks and quotations. - The connection between
the rise of the novel and the birth of Capitalism is clearly explained in
Robyn's lesson, where she finds a justification in the Protestant ethic as
the springboard for the investment of one's know-how. If on the one hand
capitalists invest their money in industrial projects, the novelist
invests his/her imagination to create a product the customer only knows
he/she wants when reading the novel. Robyn is one of the protagonists
of David Lodge's Nice Work typical example of the
semiotic materialism underlying Post-modernism. - Post-modernism cannot
distinguish between high and low art because it rejects the idea of
meaning as a reference point and, as a result, if there is no reference
meaning, there cannot be any definite truth of authority which can
establish what is high and what is low. It follows that Post-modernism
considers high and low art all the same discourse formation that can
coexist. - Post-modernism does not
believe in the concept of author because it poses the idea that since
there is not a single identity conceived of as a unique finite soul in
total control of his/her production, communication and relationships it
follows that there cannot be a single author from which text can totally
originate and therefore there is only production as a tissue of inter-textual
reference. - Readers in Post-modernism
come to the forefront for the same reason that explains the lack of a
single author. If there is no author meaning, comprehension and
interpretation shift from the author to they who create possible meanings
and interpretations from their process of reading that is from trying to
find personal meanings out of the discourse formations they come across in
the text they read. - Using the Bible as the
structuring principle of Oranges Are Not The Only Fruit is
a revolution attitude rationally conceived of to put into question the
text of the Bible seen as a dogmatic point of reference the Bible, the
very essence of western culture is used in a game-like narrative framework
to create a form of entertainment like the novel. In addition it provides
the intelligent reader a sense of direction to follow the project
displaying one of the most traditional formats of the western novel: the
Bildus Roman. Indeed the name of the chapters of the novel are symbolic
and metaphorical representations of different steps and stages of growth
in the protagonist's life. In short religion, the untouchable reference
and truth or excellence of all western culture is continually and
continuously questioned thus demonstrating that Post-modernism does not
believe in history, meaning, dogmas, authors or whatever when they come to
be considered untouchable rules that are expected to tell people what to
do and not. - Inserted parallel stories
are meant to provide the reader a parallel layer where symbolically and
thus metaphors the narrator create a silent dialogue between storyline,
plot and the inserted stories of the novel. It follows that the choice
that becomes a structural choice wants to underline the apparent
difference between realism (apparently telling about facts, history and
events) and fiction. Fiction actually means something invented, Storyline
and inserted stories are just a way for the narrator to provide the reader
with occasions for reflecting and re-searching about one's life. - The adoption of a first
person narrator for most part of the novel is another game-like choice
with which the writer Jeanette Winterson herself plays with the reader
indeed he does not easily distinguish between Jeanette the concrete living
writer Jeanette the protagonist of the novel thus making fun of all those
(critics included) that still are unable to understand fiction is not
concrete reality, fiction is an art craft, something made up and despite
all this most of the times conceived of as more real than reality itself
in a few words hypereal.